Small Anal Plugs (Butt Plugs)

Looking for a little something to tickle your fancy? Here we have our Anal Plugs in small and medium. These plugs are smaller in size than our extra large butt plugs. Anal plugs are designed for a "feeling of being filled up" and are similar to dildos but are smaller in size. Most of our Anal Plus have a notch that is designed to hold the butt plug in place once it is inserted, and a flared base to prevent it from getting lost inside the rectum. SpicyGear's favorite models are the new insertable "Gems", our favorites being the ones made of medal. Our Anal Gems are one of the hottest anal products on the market today and are loved by our staff and our anal experts!

Doc Johnson Novelties
|
sku: WTPDJ02470YU

Triple Ripple Butt Plug

MSRP:

Our Price:

Spring Sale $16.77 - $21.77

Choose Options
Doc Johnson Novelties
|
sku: WTPDJ03000-P

A-play Vibe Adventurous Anal Plug W/ Remote

MSRP:

$75.77

Choose Options
Nu Sensuelle
|
sku: WTPNCBTW57

Mini Anal Plug with Remote

MSRP:

$73.77

Choose Options
Icon Brands
|
sku: WTPIB261

9's Silver Starter Anodized Bejeweled Steel Plug

MSRP:

$12.77

Choose Options
Icon Brands
|
sku: WTPIB2123

9's Silver Starter Bejeweled Steel Plug

MSRP:

$12.77

Choose Options
Icon Brands
|
sku: WTPIB261980

9's Silver Starter Heart Bejeweled Steel Plug

MSRP:

$12.77

Choose Options
SALE

Blush Novelties
|
sku: WTPBN18510

Avant Twilight Blue Anal Plug

MSRP:

Our Price: $18.77

Spring Sale $15.99

Add to Cart
SALE

XR Brands
|
sku: WTPXRAG75-4P

Booty Sparks Gemstones Medium Heart Anal Plugs

MSRP: $69.99

Our Price: $45.77

Spring Sale $35.77

Choose Options
SI Novelties
|
sku: WTPSIN40251

Small Cock Plug Black

MSRP:

$11.77

Add to Cart
SHOTS AMERICA
|
sku: WTPSHTCHR016BLU

Chrystalino Expert Blue

MSRP:

$33.77

Add to Cart
Pipedream Products
|
sku: WTPPD461623

Anal Fantasy Remote Control Plug

MSRP:

$63.77

Add to Cart
Electric / Hustler Lingerie
|
sku: WTPELGLAS157

Glas 5 inch Rosebud Glass Butt Plug

MSRP:

$33.77

Add to Cart
XR Brands
|
sku: WTPXRAF832

Trinity Vibes 4 Pc Vibrating Anal Plug Set

MSRP:

$36.77

Choose Options
XR Brands
|
sku: WTPXRAF816SM

Master Series Peephole Clear Hollow Anal Plug

MSRP:

$19.77

Add to Cart
XR Brands
|
sku: WTPXRAF640

Tailz Hot Pink Pony Tail Anal Plug

MSRP:

$33.77

Add to Cart
XR Brands
|
sku: WTPXRAE391

Tailz Midnight Fox Glass Plug with Tail

MSRP:

$38.77

Add to Cart
Cloud 9 Novelties
|
sku: WTPWTC3009

Cloud 9 Gems Silver Chromed Anal Plug

MSRP:

Our Price:

Spring Sale $13.77 - $15.77

Choose Options
Vedo
|
sku: WTPVIM010

Rio Anal Vibe

MSRP:

$27.99

Choose Options
California Exotic Novelties
|
sku: WTPSERM687000BU

(bulk) Colt Expandable Butt Plug

MSRP:

$25.77

Add to Cart
California Exotic Novelties
|
sku: WTPSE039543

Booty Call Booty Pumper Black

MSRP:

Our Price:

Spring Sale $39.77 - $42.77

Choose Options
Rocks Off
|
sku: WTPROBTQBLKV

Butt Quiver Black

MSRP:

$36.77

Add to Cart
Perfect Fit
|
sku: WTPPERHP07

D-tunnel Plug Medium

MSRP:

$36.77

Choose Options
Perfect Fit
|
sku: WTPPERHP02B

Tunnel Plug Medium Black

MSRP:

$33.77

Add to Cart
Pipedream Products
|
sku: WTPPD466823

Anal Fantasy Inflatable Silicone Plug

MSRP:

$41.77

Add to Cart

Doc Johnson Novelties
|
sku: WTPDJ02470YU

Triple Ripple Butt Plug

Medium Triple Ripple Butt Plug Take your anal adventures to the next level with the Medium Triple Ripple Butt Plug from Doc Johnson! This uniquely designed plug features three rippling bumps that gradually increase in size for maximum sensation. Starting...

MSRP:

Our Price:

Spring Sale $16.77 - $21.77

Choose Options
Doc Johnson Novelties
|
sku: WTPDJ03000-P

A-play Vibe Adventurous Anal Plug W/ Remote

A-Play Vibe Adventurous Anal Plug – Rechargeable & Remote-Controlled Pleasure!Discover next-level anal play with the A-Play Vibe Adventurous Anal Plug by Doc Johnson. Featuring a motorized weight that thumps and thrusts inside its firm silicone body,...

MSRP:

$75.77
Choose Options
Nu Sensuelle
|
sku: WTPNCBTW57

Mini Anal Plug with Remote

Sensuelle Remote Control Mini Butt Plug – Perfect for Beginners & Beyond!The Sensuelle Remote Control Mini Butt Plug is designed for both beginners and seasoned users looking to elevate their backdoor play. This compact yet powerful anal plug delivers...

MSRP:

$73.77
Choose Options
Icon Brands
|
sku: WTPIB261

9's Silver Starter Anodized Bejeweled Steel Plug

The Nines Silver Starter Anodized Bejeweled Steel Plug. Butt plug with blue stone on its end. Sleek anodized body and bejeweled base on the anal plug perfect for beginners, designed and sized for easy insertion. Non-porous, easy to clean. Body safe...

MSRP:

$12.77
Choose Options
Icon Brands
|
sku: WTPIB2123

9's Silver Starter Bejeweled Steel Plug

From the Nines collection Silver Starter Heart Bejeweled Steel Plug with Clear Faux Stone on its end. Sleek chrome metallic body and glitzy heart shaped bejeweled base on the anal plug perfect for beginners, designed and sized for easy insertion...

MSRP:

$12.77
Choose Options
Icon Brands
|
sku: WTPIB261980

9's Silver Starter Heart Bejeweled Steel Plug

Silver Starter Heart Bejeweled Steel Plug Features:- Clear Faux Stone on its end- Sleek chrome metallic body- glitzy heart shaped bejeweled base on the anal plug- Perfect for beginners- Designed and sized for easy insertion- Non-porous- Easy to...

MSRP:

$12.77
Choose Options
SALE

Blush Novelties
|
sku: WTPBN18510

Avant Twilight Blue Anal Plug

Avant Twilight Blue Butt PlugModern, stylish, and beautiful - meet Avant Twilight! Twilight has a tapered head for easy insertion and three pleasure curves that progress in size for additional sensations during play, all with a beautiful, bright array of...

MSRP:

Our Price: $18.77

Spring Sale $15.99
Add to Cart
SALE

XR Brands
|
sku: WTPXRAG75-4P

Booty Sparks Gemstones Medium Heart Anal Plugs

Booty Sparks Gemstone Medium Heart Anal Plugs. This Sex Anal Jewlery is Perfect for Beginners and Expert Anal Plug Experts! Revitalize your booty with the positive energy of this genuine heart shaped butt plug! The real Turquoise gem embedded in the base...

MSRP: $69.99

Our Price: $45.77

Spring Sale $35.77
Choose Options
SI Novelties
|
sku: WTPSIN40251

Small Cock Plug Black

Small Cock Plug Black. Explore more, love more and feel more! Ignite by Si Novelties is there to help Ignite your passion over and over and over again! Plastics containing phthalates can be harmful to your health and have raised environmental concerns...

MSRP:

$11.77
Add to Cart
SHOTS AMERICA
|
sku: WTPSHTCHR016BLU

Chrystalino Expert Blue

Chrystalino Expert Blue Glass Butt Plug from Shots Toys. The unique shape of this beautifully handcrafted wand has been designed for both vaginal as well as anal play! Place the wand under a stream of lukewarm or cold water and the premium borosilicate...

MSRP:

$33.77
Add to Cart
Pipedream Products
|
sku: WTPPD461623

Anal Fantasy Remote Control Plug

If you have never tried anal play, the Remote Control Silicone Plug is just what you need to explore the amazing world of anal stimulation. The Remote Control Silicone Plug features a tapered tip for easy entry, while the whisper-quiet motor delivers...

MSRP:

$63.77
Add to Cart
Electric / Hustler Lingerie
|
sku: WTPELGLAS157

Glas 5 inch Rosebud Glass Butt Plug

Glas 5 inches Rosebud Glass Butt Plug Explore anal play with the unique sensation of glass. This Classic Butt Plug features a beginners friendly size and familiar shape for fans of all levels of anal play. Its flared base makes it safe to use and easy...

MSRP:

$33.77
Add to Cart
XR Brands
|
sku: WTPXRAF832

Trinity Vibes 4 Pc Vibrating Anal Plug Set

Trinity Vibes 4 Piece Vibrating Anal Plug Set from XR Brands. Excellent for adventurous beginners to backdoor play, this vibrating anal plug set includes three stimulating shaped plugs and a buzzing bullet vibe. Explore anal pleasure with 10 modes of...

MSRP:

$36.77
Choose Options
XR Brands
|
sku: WTPXRAF816SM

Master Series Peephole Clear Hollow Anal Plug

Master Series Peephole Clear Hollow Anal Plug from XR Brands. The perfect size for anal beginners or those who prefer a smaller penetration. The Peephole allows you to discover a whole new part of your partner as you peer into the depths of their ass!...

MSRP:

$19.77
Add to Cart
XR Brands
|
sku: WTPXRAF640

Tailz Hot Pink Pony Tail Anal Plug

Tailz Hot Pink Pony Tail Anal Plug from XR Brands. Enjoy hot equine action in a fun, flirty color with this smooth, full pony tail! Braid it, brush it, swish it, show it off! The tail is a full 20 inches of synthetic fiber, topped with a phthalate free...

MSRP:

$33.77
Add to Cart
XR Brands
|
sku: WTPXRAE391

Tailz Midnight Fox Glass Plug with Tail

Tailz Midnight Fox Glass Plug with Tail This long sexy tail will bring out the animal in you! Made of gleaming black man made fur, it is topped by a smooth glass anal plug, perfectly sized for pleasure. The tapered tip and classic shape helps it insert...

MSRP:

$38.77
Add to Cart
Cloud 9 Novelties
|
sku: WTPWTC3009

Cloud 9 Gems Silver Chromed Anal Plug

Cloud 9 Gems Silver Chromed Anal Plug . Cloud 9 Novelties Anal Gems Jeweled Silver Chromed Anal Plug. Anal Jewelry decorated with a stunning rainbow multicolor gem. Silver chromed wearable stainless steel butt plug featuring a jeweled beauty for your...

MSRP:

Our Price:

Spring Sale $13.77 - $15.77

Choose Options
Vedo
|
sku: WTPVIM010

Rio Anal Vibe

Vedo Silicone Toy Collection keeps things fresh in and out of the bedroom. Vedo Rio Anal Vibe arouses and ignite your deepest desires. The gently rounded tip and tapered body is perfectly designed for easy insertion and provides amazing anal pleasure...

MSRP:

$27.99
Choose Options
California Exotic Novelties
|
sku: WTPSERM687000BU

(bulk) Colt Expandable Butt Plug

(NON-RETAIL, BULK PACKAGING) Expand your anal most pleasures. COLT Gear Expandable Butt Plug is made from latex and rubber inflating butt plug with easy purge valve. Measures 5 inches in height 1.5 inches wide and 4 inches wide inflated. Lube included...

MSRP:

$25.77
Add to Cart
California Exotic Novelties
|
sku: WTPSE039543

Booty Call Booty Pumper Black

Booty Call Booty Pumper Black. Inflatable plug with superior suction cup base. Easy squeeze bulb. Quick air release valve. Pliable and durable. Safe and pure for body and pleasure made using phthalate free materials: Silicone probe, hose, bulb, ABS...

MSRP:

Our Price:

Spring Sale $39.77 - $42.77

Choose Options
Rocks Off
|
sku: WTPROBTQBLKV

Butt Quiver Black

Butt Quiver Black is powered by Rocks Off the world famous RO-80mm 7 Speed Vibrating Bullet. 7 quivering settings for total fulfillment. 100% waterproof with battery included. 3 inches insert-able length and 1.5 inches diameter. Tapered angled tip for...

MSRP:

$36.77
Add to Cart
Perfect Fit
|
sku: WTPPERHP07

D-tunnel Plug Medium

The Double Tunnel Plug . Butt plug features two plugs that slightly taper to the tip which makes it one of the most innovative butt plugs available on the market. In addition to being a standard butt plug, you can use the tunnel hole that goes all the...

MSRP:

$36.77
Choose Options
Perfect Fit
|
sku: WTPPERHP02B

Tunnel Plug Medium Black

You have never seen anything like this; it is the coolest innovation in butt plugs since they came on the market. Instead of just plugging someone's butt, you can open it and use the incredible tunnel hole that goes all the way through the plug. Besides...

MSRP:

$33.77
Add to Cart
Pipedream Products
|
sku: WTPPD466823

Anal Fantasy Inflatable Silicone Plug

If you are an advanced anal player, this Inflatable Silicone Plug is just what you need to take your anal stimulation to the extreme! Featuring a tapered tip to ease insertion, the Inflatable Silicone Plug can expand your rear to extreme new widths! It...

MSRP:

$41.77
Add to Cart